I very rarely walk out of films. I always feel that you should give the director the benefit of the doubt and see the work in its entirety. However, I only saw half of this adaptation of the Philip Pullman book and pretty much had the sense that this was a lost cause for me. I was enthralled by the 'His Dark Materials' trilogy. They were a lively, refreshing and exciting set of books with a central character, Lyra, that provided the necessary identification in the midst of a story that as Pullman says 'is about killing God'.
The film looks wonderful. The parallel world Oxford and the journey to Norway were beautifully designed and presented. The visual effects again were excellent, the main characters' 'daemons' (souls in animal form) and the polar bears all stunningly realised, the airships and landscapes equally brilliant. It's got a great cast and a charismatic young actress playing the lead.
But it lacks any cinematic imagination. It's a dull plod through a very fractured version of the original story and I felt that anyone not aware of the books might find it puzzling and baffling as there is not enough in the way of logical building blocks to make you relate to the story or the characters. The concept of the daemons is barely sketched in and their precious importance to their owners isn't explained at all. Several characters in the book (Farder Coram, Serafina Pekkla and Lord Asriel) are reduced to cyphers and barely make an impression on the story. And that's a shame because the director ends up wasting a great collection of British thesps and new talent like Eva Green. To me it feels as if the director is simply trying to get from one plot point to another to survive the experience and has forgotten to imbue any of it with a spark of life.
Looking back at the troubled history of the production, to me it is clear that Chris Weitz was not the right director for this. He'd already abandoned the production only to replace his replacement and he had allegedly feared that he wasn't up to the job. Weitz bravely tries to marshall all the elements here and does retain some of the anti-religion theme of the book but with the best will in the world his efforts lack clarity and scenes just seem to tumble one after another without any real dramatic climaxes. The narrative doesn't peak at all where it should. The plot is crushed into a short running time that would imply a briskly edited high stakes adventure but it comes over with the opposite effect with scenes dragged out in a single monotone and no one character given the breathing space to affect the story. Words leave the mouths of the actors and you are literally moved on to the next scene without any consideration.
Apparently, the ending is also disappointing in that it drops the original tragic close of the book and opts out of the story at an earlier juncture to provide a 'happy' ending. Glad I wasn't around to witness that as it would have added further fuel to the fire. I'm baffled as to how a spirited, often controversial, fantasy was reduced to this very pale, barely animated, cinematic doppleganger.
A real disappointment.
The Golden Compass (Cert PG - Released 5th December 2007. Directed by Chris Weitz)
- Freelance writer and film and television researcher (for hire).
He has contributed to a number of books and websites about British archive television and cinema as well as recent television series including work for Moviemail, Frame Rated and Arrow Video. Publications include I.B Tauris's 'Doctor Who: The Eleventh Hour - A Critical
Celebration of the Matt Smith and Steven Moffat Era' (2013) and 'Doctor
Who - The Pandorica Opens' (2010).
- Adventures in Prime Time
- Behind the Sofa
- Blogtor Who
- British Television Drama
- Cardigans & Tweed
- Dez Skinn
- Dirty Modern Scoundrel
- Doctor Who Appreciation Society
- Doctor Who Newspage
- Feeling Listless
- Frame Rated
- Gareth Bundy's Blog
- Green Carnation Prize
- Int. Jason Arnopp's Mind - Day/Night
- Island of Dreams
- Jonathan Melville
- Ka-os Theory
- Lady Don't Fall Backwards
- Life of Wylie
- Life on Magrs
- Narrative Drive
- Paul Mount's World of Stuff
- Pseudo Random Noise
- Radio Free Skaro
- TV Lover
- Tachyon TV
- Tardis Newsroom
- Television Heaven
- The Custard TV
- The Digital Bits
- The Fan Can
- The Medium is Not Enough
- The Railway Arms
- The Thumbcast
- Thierry Attard's Double Feature
- from the north...
The Book(s) What I Wrote
"Whether you’re a fan of the show under Moffat or not, it offers an intriguing, insightful look at all aspects of the series" 7/10 - Starburst, January 2014
"A worthy addition to serious texts on Doctor Who" - Doctor Who Magazine 431, February 2011
"an impressive work, imbued with so much analytical love and passion, and is an absolute must-read for any fan" N. Blake - Amazon 4/5 stars
"...mixes the intellectual and the emotional very well...it's proper media criticism" 9/10 - The Medium Is Not Enough
"... an up-to-date guide that isn’t afraid to shy away from the more controversial aspects of the series" 8/10 - Total SciFi Online
"...well-informed new angles on familiar episodes... this is a great read from start to finish" - Bertie Fox - Amazon 4/5 stars
"Frank Collins has produced a book that is fiercely idiosyncratic, displays a wide-ranging intellect the size of a planet, but which is also endearingly open and inclusive in its desire to share its expansive knowledge..." 4/5 - Horrorview.com
"The book is great! It makes you think, it makes you work. It encourages you to go back and watch the series with a whole new perspective..." - G.R. Bundy's Blog: Telly Stuff And Things